Skip to content

Making Connections

isee systems blog

Making Connections

  • About
  • More Connections
Search

The Politics of Economic Recovery

Updated: December 3, 2010December 3, 2010Filed under: Systems Thinking3 Comments

Editor’s Note: This is a guest post from isee’s training and consulting partner, Corey Peck of Lexidyne LLC.

The mid-term elections are now a month behind us and the political airwaves are still abuzz with commentary about the results.  Exit polls showed that unemployment was at the top of most voters’ list of issues, and that concerns about the federal government’s financial condition (record deficits and debt levels) were a hot topic as well.  Voters appeared to be asking “How can the federal government spend so much money and have so little positive impact on the nation’s economy?” 

The responses by politicians to such an important question are all over the map.  Democrats are claiming that economic conditions would have been much worse if not for massive federal bailouts and stimulus spending.  Republicans are touting the situation as a death knoll for the Obama platform in an effort to position themselves for 2012.  And the Tea Party movement has emerged to push for a roll-back of what they see as an intrusive and ineffective “Big Government”.

But, this political posturing reminds me that one of the true strengths of Systems Thinking is to force people to think very clearly and very operationally about the structure/behavior link embedded in such cases.  A little over a year ago, we sat down with Dr. Mark Paich, who used some very simple stock/flow language and some well-established principles of macroeconomics to lay out some relevant dynamics about the economic crisis and its aftermath:

  • Why the collapse of the housing market made consumers re-evaluate their net asset position and hence started saving more of their incomes to pay off high interest credit card debt.
  • How such actions on the part of consumers, in aggregate, kicked off a vicious cycle of decreased spending and contracting national output.
  • Why government stimulus spending could close some, but not all, of the gap left by suddenly thrifty consumers, and that the recovery was likely to be a long, slow one.

We certainly don’t know how the future will play out, but the data suggest that consumers are indeed cutting back spending, and paying off debt.  (The Bureau of Economic Analysis has terrific historical data on household balance sheets and income.)  The unemployment numbers remain stubbornly high (around 9.5%), and although the recession is technically over, few economists are predicting rapid post-crisis economic expansion.

For a bit of clarity amidst all the rhetoric, you may want to check out Mark’s video offering.  His model and associated explanation do not provide a “magic bullet” of a solution, but they do provide some substance (and perhaps insight) to this vexing situation.  Now if only the politicians could follow suit!

To read a previous blog post about Modeling the Economic Crisis or view a 5-minute video trailer, click here.

Systems Thinking
  • crisis
  • economy
  • government
  • housing
  • stimulus

Post navigation

Previous Post:

What are “Mental Models”? Part 2

Next Post:

Shifting the Burden

About the Author

Corey Peck

All posts byCorey Peck

Hide

Categories

  • Education (4)
  • isee NetSim (3)
  • isee.NET Framework (1)
  • Modeling Tips (32)
  • News & Announcements (15)
  • STELLA & iThink (14)
  • Stories from the Field (5)
  • Systems Thinking (8)
  • Training (6)

Archives

Browse by keyword

2D array archetypes arrays Barry Richmond Bass diffusion builtins calibration Causal Loop CLD command line conferences crisis data diffusion Education environment export game graphical function h1n1 healthcare housing import iThink/STELLA market dynamics MODSIM modules mortgage netsim optimization Physics policy price releases scholarship software spatial Stella storytelling System Dynamics Society Systems Thinking Version 9.1.2 video webinar workshop

Recent Posts

  • COVID-19: Modeling Distributions of Incubation and Recovery Times April 1, 2020
  • Multiobjective Optimization January 9, 2018
  • Optimizing Model Performance December 22, 2017
  • Calibration in Stella® December 15, 2017
  • Drifting Goals March 9, 2016

RSS System Dynamics Forum

Recent Comments

  • best apps review on About
  • digital software on Modeling the Economic Crisis
  • Mishawaka Indiana on What are “Mental Models”?
  • La Paz Indiana on XMILE – An open standard for system dynamics models
  • Bristol Indiana on Modeling the Economic Crisis

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
Products
Software (v1.3)
  • Stella Architect
  • Stella Professional
  • Stella Designer
  • Stella Simulator
  • iThink
  • Feature Updates
  • Policies
  • Publishing Options
  • License Agreement
Free Software
  • Stella Online
  • isee Player
  • Stella Architect Trial
Solutions
Consulting
  • Systems Innovation Practice
Common Applications
  • Business
  • Education
  • Research
  • Government
  • Energy
  • Health
  • Agriculture
  • Manufacturing
  • Conservation
Quick Links
About
  • isee systems
  • Systems Thinking
  • Barry Richmond Scholarship
Resources
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Product Help
  • Examples
  • Request Support
  • Request Quote
  • Systems in Focus
  • Quick Tips
  • Legacy Tutorials
News and Events
Upcoming Workshops
  • Introduction to Dynamic Modeling
  • Whole Systems Partnership
Newsletter
  • The Connector
Recent Webinars
  • Model Mysteries
Recent Training
  • Systems Thinking Practice
Press Release
  • Stella Architect Release

  Phone: (603) 448-4990   Email: info@iseesystems.com

   Monday - Friday: 9:00 am - 5:00 pm EDT | Saturday - Sunday: Closed
Wheelock Office Park | 31 Old Etna Rd, Suite 7N | Lebanon, NH 03766 | US

isee systems inc. holds registered trademark rights over the following: iThink®, STELLA®, Stella®, isee systems® and claims the following trademarks; isee NetSim™, Stella Live™, Causal Lens™ and Stella Online™.

Terms of Use

© 2017. isee systems inc . All rights reserved.